Mistakes to Avoid with Life Insurance Beneficiaries

Feb 23, 2023

An important part of a complete estate plan is making sure your beneficiary designations will accomplish your goals.  Naming beneficiaries for your life insurance death benefits may seem simple, but designating beneficiaries requires careful preparation.

This article will discuss some life insurance beneficiary mistakes to avoid.

  1. Naming a minor child

Life insurance companies won’t pay life insurance death benefits directly to minors (anyone under the age of 18).  If benefits are payable to a minor child, a court appointed guardian will be required to receive the life insurance proceeds. This process will be more costly and creates unnecessary headaches for your loved one.  If a guardianship is required, the guardian will administer the proceeds until the child reaches 18, and generally the court will impose strict restrictions on the use of the funds before age 18.

A better alternative is to either set up a trust to benefit the child and name the trust as the beneficiary of the policy or name an adult custodian for the life insurance proceeds under the Uniform Transfers to Minor Act directly with the life insurance company.

  1. Making a dependent ineligible for government benefits

If your intended beneficiary, such as a child with special needs, is currently receiving government assistance such as Medicaid or Supplemental Social Security Income, he or she may lose eligibility for government assistance upon receiving the life insurance benefits directly. A special needs trust will allow your intended beneficiary to maintain eligibility for government programs and have a source of funds managed by a trustee to provide for items or services not covered by the government program.

  1. Assuming your will governs the distribution of proceeds

A life insurance policy is a contract and the distribution of the death benefit is determined by the terms of the life insurance policy and your beneficiary designations for that policy.  The terms of your will do not determine how the life insurance proceeds will pass as long as you have a valid beneficiary. Your will only applies if you do not have a named beneficiary to your life insurance policy (generally because your named beneficiary or beneficiaries have predeceased you).  It is important to contact your insurer to confirm your current beneficiaries and to change your beneficiary if needed to accomplish your wishes.

  1. Forgetting to update

You should review your beneficiaries every two or three years and after any major life event, such as marriage, the birth of a child or divorce to make sure the beneficiaries still reflect your wishes.  This is particularly important after a divorce, the divorce in and of itself does not necessarily void any beneficiary designations.

You should also keep good records of the beneficiaries named to help the person or persons handling your affairs or if the insurance company cannot locate the beneficiary designation paperwork.

  1. Be Clear in Your Designations

Be careful in how you complete beneficiary designation forms. Particularly as to what happens if a named beneficiary is deceased. The form may indicate that the deceased beneficiary’s share will be distributed to the remaining beneficiaries, or it may allow you to specify that the deceased beneficiaries share will be distributed to his or her descendants, per stirpes.  Per stirpes means the proceeds are divided by branch of the family. You can specify either method on the beneficiary designation forms, and both are acceptable options.

For example, you want to leave the money to your two children, Bob and Sue. Bob has three children and Sue has one child. Now suppose Bob dies before you die. If your beneficiary designation says that Bob’s share will pass, per stirpes, then half the money would go to Bob’s three children, and half would go to Sue. If you do not designate per stirpes or the company does not allow such a designation, then Bob’s share will pass to Sue.

It is very important to carefully read and complete these forms

It is also very important to be specific when you name beneficiaries. Instead of “my children” or my “grandchildren” list their names.  This may seem unnecessary, but some companies may require probate court action to determine who are your children or grandchildren if they are not named on the beneficiary form.  All of this will take more time and money.

  1. Leave a Record

Life insurance benefits can only be claimed if your loved ones know they exist.  It is important to tell the person or persons who will handle your estate that you have the policy and how to find the information on the policy.  Often locating current life insurance policies can be like locating a needle in a hay stack.  Keeping good records will make sure that the life insurance proceeds are actually collected with the least amount of effort.

  1. Giving money with no strings attached

We discussed above why naming minors is not a good idea, but naming an adult as beneficiary may not always be the best result. Although they are legally old enough to receive the benefits without court involvement, they may not be sufficiently able to handle the money or they may have a substance abuse issue or mental health issue. A trust allows you to put rules in place for how the money is dispersed to the beneficiary such as delaying the receipt of a large influx of money until the beneficiary reaches a certain age or ages or allowing the trustee to make distributions in the best interest of the beneficiary.

If is very important to consider how your intended beneficiary may handle funds received.

  1. Naming only a primary beneficiary

Many policies name a spouse as beneficiary, but do not name a contingent beneficiary. If something would happen to a couple at the same time or in quick succession, the life insurance policy will need to pass through probate.  When there is no living beneficiary, the life insurance benefit typically goes into the estate and is subject to probate.  Subjecting the proceeds to probate will delay the distribution to your beneficiaries and the life insurance proceeds, which normally would be protected from creditors, will now be required to pay off creditors.

It is a good idea to name a primary and contingent or secondary beneficiary. If the primary beneficiary dies before you do, then the money passes to the secondary beneficiary.

If you have any questions about your life insurance beneficiaries, please contact me.

Elizabeth Schmitz practices estate planning, probate and elder law. Her practice allows her to guide families and individuals as they provide for themselves and their loved ones during all stages of life.

Elizabeth has worked extensively in the field of estate planning and administration. As a member of the legal department and then as a trust officer at National City Bank she administered estates and trusts and provided legal advice. She has been in private practice since 1994 drafting estate plans, administering estates, and assisting her clients through the transitions in their lives.

You might also like….

OFFICE ADDRESS

1900 Polaris Parkway,
Suite 450
Columbus, OH 43240

OFFICE ADDRESS

1900 Polaris Parkway,
Suite 450
Columbus, OH 43240

STAY UP-TO-DATE on matters that matter to you.
Subscribe to our monthly MAKING PLANS newsletter.